Have Equity But a Low Mortgage Rate? How to Decide Whether to Move
Mindy Jones, Broker Owner
Realtor® & Arizona State Broker | Exactly What to Say® Certified Guide | Certified Quadrant3 Leadership Coach | Speaker, Trainer & Community...
Realtor® & Arizona State Broker | Exactly What to Say® Certified Guide | Certified Quadrant3 Leadership Coach | Speaker, Trainer & Community...
Maybe you bought your home several years ago. Maybe you refinanced when interest rates were historically low. Either way, you've built equity, you've got a monthly payment you're comfortable with, and on paper, you're in a pretty great position.
There's just one problem.
Your house doesn't fit your life anymore.
Maybe your family needs more space. Maybe the kids have moved out and you're ready for something smaller. Maybe you want to be closer to work, family, or the people and places you love.
Or maybe you simply want a different kind of home.
But every time you think about moving, you remember your mortgage rate and wonder:
"Am I crazy to give up this payment?"
You're not the only one asking that question.
Many homeowners throughout the East Valley and greater Phoenix area are wrestling with the same decision. They have equity and options, but they're also understandably reluctant to exchange a low mortgage rate for a higher one.
At The Amy Jones Group, we don't think the answer is always to move, and we don't think the answer is always to stay.
We think the answer starts with understanding what you have, what you want, and what the tradeoffs actually look like.
First, Your Equity and Your Mortgage Payment Are Two Different Things
Let's start with the basics.
Home equity is the difference between what your home is worth and what you owe against it.
For example, imagine your home is worth $650,000 and you owe $300,000 on your mortgage.
That would give you approximately $350,000 in equity before selling expenses and other adjustments.
But that doesn't mean you would receive a $350,000 check if you sold.
You'll also need to account for selling costs, negotiated concessions, any additional liens, and other transaction expenses.
If those expenses totaled a hypothetical $40,000, you might have approximately $310,000 in proceeds after paying off your mortgage.
Your actual proceeds would depend on the sale price, mortgage payoff, negotiated terms, and closing costs. This is why we start with a personalized estimate rather than an online home value alone.
That equity could potentially help you purchase your next home with a larger down payment and a smaller mortgage.
And that's where the conversation starts getting interesting.
Don't Compare Interest Rates. Compare Your Actual Housing Costs.
Let's say your current mortgage has a very low fixed interest rate.
It's natural to compare that rate with what a lender might offer today and immediately feel like moving is a bad financial decision.
But the interest rate is only one piece of the equation.
What matters is the payment on your next home, including:
Principal and interest: The amount you're borrowing, your loan term, and the interest rate all affect this payment.
Property taxes and insurance: These expenses may change when you move, even if the new home's purchase price is similar to your current home's value.
HOA fees: A different community or type of property may have additional monthly or annual costs.
Maintenance and utilities: The age, size, condition, and features of the new property may change what it costs to maintain.
Your available equity: A larger down payment may help offset some of the impact of higher mortgage rates by reducing the amount you need to finance.
A new mortgage at a higher interest rate doesn't automatically mean your payment will be dramatically higher. But it doesn't guarantee your payment will be similar, either.
We need to compare actual homes, actual financing options, and actual monthly expenses.
Start With Why You Want to Move
Before we talk about pricing, mortgage rates, or loan programs, we like to ask a different question:
"What would a different home make possible for you?"
Would it mean:
• Less time commuting and more time with your family?
• A single-story home that better fits your long-term needs?
• A smaller property with less maintenance?
• More room for a growing family, visitors, or working from home?
• A location closer to the people and activities that matter most?
• A home that better matches the way you want to spend the next ten years?
Those aren't small considerations.
And while they don't erase the financial impact of moving, they absolutely belong in the decision.
A mortgage payment is an important number. But it's not the only measure of how well a home is working for you.
Five Strategies Worth Exploring Before You Decide to Stay Put
1. Use your equity strategically.
Instead of automatically shopping at the top of your budget, consider what happens when you apply more of your sale proceeds toward your next down payment.
A lower loan balance could help make a higher interest rate more manageable. Just be sure to preserve appropriate savings for emergencies, repairs, moving expenses, and other priorities.
2. Look at a different type of home or community.
Sometimes the goal isn't necessarily a bigger or more expensive home. It's a home that works differently.
A townhome, patio home, single-story property, smaller house, or different neighborhood may provide the lifestyle you're looking for without requiring the same size mortgage as another traditional single-family home.
Of course, some lower-maintenance properties also come with higher HOA fees, so it's important to compare the complete cost.
3. Explore seller concessions and mortgage rate buydowns.
Depending on the property and the negotiation, a seller or builder may be willing to contribute toward closing costs or an interest rate buydown.
A permanent rate buydown generally involves paying discount points to obtain a lower contractual mortgage rate. A temporary buydown may reduce payments for an initial period before they increase to the regular note-payment amount.
These strategies have costs, limits, and qualification requirements. We want to understand the full payment and how long it takes for any upfront cost to produce a financial benefit.
And with a temporary buydown, you should be comfortable with the full payment after the introductory period ends.
4. Consider your timing and the order of your transactions.
Some homeowners prefer to sell first so they know exactly how much equity they have available.
Others want to find the right home before selling and may consider options such as a sale contingency, bridge financing, or a home equity line of credit, subject to lender approval.
There may also be opportunities to coordinate closing dates or negotiate a temporary post-closing occupancy arrangement when both parties agree.
Each approach has advantages, costs, and risks. The right strategy depends on your financial flexibility, the properties involved, and current market conditions.
5. Compare moving with improving the home you already own.
Maybe staying put is the better option after all.
If a renovation would solve the issues driving your desire to move, let's understand what it would cost and whether it would realistically give you the result you're hoping for.
Not every issue can be solved with a renovation, especially when the real motivation involves location, layout, or lifestyle.
But it's a valuable alternative to evaluate before making a major decision.
What About Buying Before You Sell?
One concern we hear from homeowners is that they don't want to sell their current house without knowing where they're going next.
We understand that.
Depending on your situation, there may be financing options that allow you to purchase your next property before your current one closes.
That could include bridge financing, certain cash-backed purchase programs, or a home equity line of credit arranged before listing your property.
These options aren't appropriate or available for everyone. They may involve additional fees, lender requirements, financing risk, or the temporary responsibility of carrying two properties.
But they're worth discussing if the logistics of moving, rather than the desire to move, are what's holding you back.
Our job is to help you understand what's possible and coordinate the right professionals to evaluate the financial details.
Sometimes the Best Decision Is to Wait. Sometimes It Isn't.
Here's where we think real estate advice needs to become more personal.
For one homeowner, keeping a low mortgage payment and making a few improvements might be the smartest decision.
For another, moving closer to family or finding a more manageable home may be worth a higher monthly cost.
For someone else, selling now, renting temporarily, and buying later might provide the flexibility they need.
And sometimes the right answer is to make a move now, using available equity and thoughtful financing to create a payment that works.
The goal isn't to justify moving. The goal is to understand what moving would actually cost and whether the benefits are worth it to you.
Frequently Asked Questions About Moving With a Low Mortgage Rate
Can I take my current low mortgage rate with me when I buy another house?
With a typical U.S. fixed-rate mortgage, you generally cannot transfer the existing loan and interest rate to a completely different property. A new purchase usually requires new financing at the rates and terms available at that time. Certain specialized mortgage arrangements may differ.
Can I use the equity in my current home as the down payment on my next home?
Yes, many homeowners use proceeds from selling one home toward the purchase of another. The timing of the transactions and any financing requirements need to be planned carefully.
Could my new mortgage payment be lower even with a higher rate?
Possibly. If you're buying a less expensive property or borrowing substantially less money, a higher rate doesn't automatically mean a higher payment. You'll need to compare the complete housing costs to know.
Can I lower my payment after selling my current home?
Some loans and lenders allow a mortgage recast, which involves making a significant principal payment and having the remaining loan balance re-amortized over the remaining term. It generally doesn't change the interest rate, and not every mortgage is eligible. Ask your lender about the requirements before relying on this strategy.
Will I have to pay capital gains tax if I sell?
Not necessarily. Many homeowners who meet applicable IRS requirements may qualify to exclude up to $250,000 of gain from the sale of a primary residence, or up to $500,000 for qualifying married couples filing jointly. Taxable gain is calculated differently from home equity or net sale proceeds. A qualified tax professional can help you understand your situation.
What if I don't know how much my home is worth?
That's the perfect place to start. A personalized market analysis can help estimate a realistic sale price, while a seller net proceeds estimate helps show how much money you might have available for your next move.
Let's Look at the Whole Picture, Not Just Your Interest Rate
At The Amy Jones Group, some of the most meaningful conversations we have with homeowners don't end with an immediate decision to sell.
Sometimes we help someone realize they should stay and make improvements.
Sometimes we help them create a plan for a move six months or a year down the road.
And sometimes we discover that moving is more financially realistic than they expected.
That's what thoughtful real estate guidance should look like.
If you own a home in Chandler, Gilbert, Mesa, Queen Creek, Tempe, Phoenix, Scottsdale, or the surrounding Arizona communities, we'd love to help you evaluate your options.
We'll look at what your home could sell for, estimate your potential proceeds, explore the types of homes that might better fit your needs, and help you understand how the payments could compare with the assistance of a lending professional.
You don't need to decide whether you're moving before we have the conversation.
You just need to know what might be possible.
Connect with The Amy Jones Group and let's look at your next chapter together.
Helpful resources: CFPB Guide to Comparing Mortgage Offers, CFPB Guide to Mortgage Points and Credits, and IRS Guidance on the Sale of Your Home. Mortgage and tax considerations vary by situation. Consult a qualified lender and tax professional before making financial decisions.
Thinking about buying a home?
Whether you're buying your first home, making a move, or just starting to explore your options, we're here to make the process feel simple. From the first conversation to getting the keys, we'll guide you every step of the way.