Been Renting for Years? How to Buy a Home Even With Higher Interest Rates
Mindy Jones, Broker Owner
Realtor® & Arizona State Broker | Exactly What to Say® Certified Guide | Certified Quadrant3 Leadership Coach | Speaker, Trainer & Community...
Realtor® & Arizona State Broker | Exactly What to Say® Certified Guide | Certified Quadrant3 Leadership Coach | Speaker, Trainer & Community...
Maybe you've been renting for five years. Maybe it's been twenty. Maybe you owned a home once, but life changed, and you've been renting ever since.
And every time you start thinking about buying a home, the same thought comes up:
"I'd love to own a home, but aren't interest rates way too high right now?"
We hear this conversation often, and it's an important one. Because for many renters, the concern isn't necessarily that they've done the math and decided buying doesn't work. It's that they've heard so much about mortgage rates that buying feels out of reach before they've ever explored their options.
At The Amy Jones Group, we believe your first step toward homeownership shouldn't be a sales pitch. It should be understanding your numbers, your options, and what makes sense for your life.
Let's start there.
First, What Does a Higher Mortgage Interest Rate Actually Mean?
When you purchase a home with a mortgage, you're borrowing money from a lender and paying interest on the amount you owe.
The interest rate is one of the factors that determines your monthly mortgage payment. Generally, when rates increase, borrowing the same amount of money costs more each month.
Here's a simple example using a $300,000 mortgage with a 30-year fixed rate:
At 6% interest: Your monthly principal and interest payment would be approximately $1,799.
At 7% interest: Your monthly principal and interest payment would be approximately $1,996.
That's a difference of about $197 per month for the same loan amount.
These are illustrative rates, not current lender quotes. The calculations also exclude property taxes, homeowners insurance, mortgage insurance, HOA fees, and other costs of ownership.
And this is the important part: You don't have to understand every detail of mortgage financing to begin exploring homeownership. You just need to understand what the total monthly payment would mean for your budget.
That's where a good lender and a knowledgeable real estate team come in.
Stop Asking "Are Rates Too High?" and Start Asking "What Would My Payment Be?"
Imagine you're paying $2,300 per month in rent.
Does that mean you can afford a $2,300 mortgage payment? Not necessarily.
Homeownership includes expenses renters may not pay directly, such as maintenance, repairs, property taxes, homeowners insurance, and potentially HOA fees.
But it also doesn't automatically mean buying is out of reach.
The better question is: What home price, loan program, and down payment would create a total monthly housing cost that fits comfortably into my life?
That question gives us something useful to work with.
Instead of starting with the most expensive home a lender might approve you for, we like to work backward from a payment that makes sense for your actual budget.
Because being approved to spend a certain amount and feeling comfortable spending that amount are two very different things.
You Might Not Need 20% Down to Buy a Home
One of the biggest misconceptions about buying a home is that you have to save 20% of the purchase price before you can start looking.
While a larger down payment can reduce your monthly payment and potentially lower borrowing costs, many buyers have other options.
Depending on eligibility, available financing may include:
Conventional loan programs: Some options, including Fannie Mae's HomeReady program, allow qualified borrowers to purchase with as little as 3% down.
FHA loans: These government-insured loans may offer more flexible qualification options, including down payments as low as 3.5% for eligible borrowers.
VA loans: Eligible veterans, active-duty service members, and certain surviving spouses may qualify for financing without a required down payment in many circumstances.
USDA loans: Some eligible buyers purchasing qualifying properties in designated areas may have access to no-down-payment financing.
Down payment assistance: Certain programs can help qualifying buyers with down payment or closing costs, depending on the program and available funding.
There are still closing costs, financial qualifications, and other expenses to plan for. But don't assume the down payment alone makes buying impossible.
Arizona Buyers Have Additional Programs Worth Exploring
If you're renting in Arizona, it's worth asking a lender about the state's down payment assistance options.
For example, Arizona's Home Plus program offers qualifying buyers down payment and closing cost assistance and is available statewide, including Maricopa County. Assistance terms, income limits, loan options, and eligibility requirements apply.
Another program, Arizona Is Home, serves eligible first-time buyers in certain Arizona communities, including Pinal County, but is not available for purchases in Maricopa or Pima counties. Funding and geographic requirements apply.
These programs are different, and assistance isn't automatically free money. It may involve a second mortgage, repayment requirements, or tradeoffs in the interest rate on the first mortgage.
That's why we recommend reviewing the complete loan terms and total costs with a participating lender before deciding whether an assistance program is the best option.
You can learn more about the programs and current requirements directly from the Arizona Industrial Development Authority.
What If Your Credit Isn't Perfect or You've Owned a Home Before?
Maybe your credit took a hit during a difficult season of life. Maybe you went through a divorce, had medical expenses, changed careers, or sold a home years ago and haven't purchased another one.
That doesn't automatically mean homeownership is off the table forever.
Different loan programs have different credit, income, debt, and past-homeownership requirements.
And here's something that surprises some renters: You don't necessarily have to be buying your very first home to qualify for certain low-down-payment loan programs.
If you aren't ready to qualify today, a lender can help identify what needs to change. Maybe that's paying down a credit card, documenting your income, building savings, correcting a credit report error, or simply allowing more time after a major financial event.
There is a big difference between "not right now" and "never."
Five Steps You Can Take Right Now
1. Determine a monthly payment you're comfortable with. Consider what you're currently paying in rent, your other financial obligations, and the amount of money you want left for savings and everyday life.
2. Review your credit and monthly debts. Knowing where you stand helps you identify opportunities for improvement without guessing.
3. Talk with a mortgage professional before assuming you won't qualify. A good lender can explain financing options, estimated payments, upfront costs, and what your next steps might look like.
4. Explore available homes within your actual budget. You may find that certain locations, home sizes, condos, townhomes, or new construction opportunities offer options you hadn't considered.
5. Create a plan, even if buying is six or twelve months away. You can use that time to build savings, strengthen your finances, and learn the market. You don't have to start shopping for houses tomorrow to make progress today.
What About Buying Now and Refinancing Later?
You may have heard someone say, "Marry the house, date the rate."
While there's some truth to the idea that a mortgage can sometimes be refinanced later, we think that advice needs an important disclaimer.
Buy a home you can comfortably afford with the financing available today.
If interest rates decrease in the future, refinancing might become an option. But lower future rates aren't guaranteed, and refinancing depends on your financial situation, property value, lender approval, and the costs involved.
You shouldn't need a future refinance for your home to be affordable.
Frequently Asked Questions for Longtime Renters
Is it smarter to keep renting until interest rates go down?
Sometimes it is. Sometimes buying now is a better fit. It depends on your rent, financial stability, available savings, plans for the future, and the total cost of owning. There isn't one right answer for everyone.
Do I need to be a first-time homebuyer to get assistance?
Not always. Requirements vary by program. Some options are available to eligible repeat buyers, while others have specific first-time buyer rules or exceptions.
Can I buy with less-than-perfect credit?
Possibly. Credit requirements depend on the loan program and lender. The first step is understanding your current situation rather than assuming you're automatically disqualified.
Does renting for a long time hurt my chances?
Not simply because you've been renting. Lenders consider your financial qualifications, and certain programs may be able to consider documented, on-time rental payments as part of the underwriting process.
Should I start looking at houses before talking to a lender?
You can absolutely explore neighborhoods and learn what's available. But before seriously shopping or making an offer, understanding your financing and estimated monthly payment will help you make more confident decisions.
You Don't Need to Be Ready to Buy to Start the Conversation
Maybe you'll discover you're closer to homeownership than you thought.
Maybe you'll find that buying isn't the right move this year, but you can be in a much stronger position next year.
Both are valuable outcomes.
At The Amy Jones Group, we help buyers throughout the East Valley and greater Phoenix area understand their options, connect with lending professionals, and create realistic paths toward their housing goals.
If you've been renting and wondering whether owning a home could be possible, let's find out together.
There's no pressure to buy. Just a chance to get real information about your options and what might make sense for you.
Reach out to The Amy Jones Group and let's start with a conversation.
Additional homebuyer resources: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: Homebuying Budget, Fannie Mae HomeReady, and Arizona Down Payment Assistance Programs. Loan programs, rates, and eligibility requirements are subject to change. Consult a qualified lender for financing guidance.
Thinking about buying a home?
Whether you're buying your first home, making a move, or just starting to explore your options, we're here to make the process feel simple. From the first conversation to getting the keys, we'll guide you every step of the way.